| 2009 Fantasy Baseball Draft Order | ||||||||
| 1st Round | 2nd Round | 3rd Round | 4th Round | 5th Round | 6th Round | 7th Round | 8th Round | |
| 1 | Guilmet | Paul | Scott | Guilmet | Guilmet | Mike | Chris | Craig |
| 2 | Scott | Rick | Craig | Jeff | Craig | Dave | Guilmet | Paul |
| 3 | Jeff | Eric | Mike | Steve | Farrelly | Steve | Dave | Steve |
| 4 | Steve | Craig | Paul | Rick | Eric | Rick | Mike | Farrelly |
| 5 | Dave | Farrelly | Eric | Farrelly | Paul | Scott | Scott | Eric |
| 6 | Chris | Mike | Dave | Chris | Chris | Jeff | Rick | Jeff |
| 7 | Mike | Chris | Chris | Dave | Jeff | Chris | Jeff | Rick |
| 8 | Farrelly | Dave | Farrelly | Eric | Scott | Paul | Eric | Scott |
| 9 | Craig | Steve | Rick | Paul | Rick | Eric | Farrelly | Mike |
| 10 | Eric | Jeff | Steve | Mike | Steve | Farrelly | Steve | Dave |
| 11 | Rick | Scott | Jeff | Craig | Dave | Craig | Paul | Guilmet |
| 12 | Paul | Guilmet | Guilmet | Scott | Mike | Guilmet | Craig | Chris |
| 9th Round | 10th Round | 11th Round | 12th Round | 13th Round | 14th Round | 15th Round | 16th Round | |
| 1 | Guilmet | Craig | Paul | Craig | Rick | Farrelly | Rick | Eric |
| 2 | Rick | Eric | Eric | Guilmet | Steve | Scott | Chris | Jeff |
| 3 | Scott | Jeff | Dave | Chris | Jeff | Eric | Guilmet | Mike |
| 4 | Dave | Chris | Jeff | Steve | Dave | Craig | Craig | Scott |
| 5 | Paul | Farrelly | Mike | Rick | Guilmet | Mike | Farrelly | Paul |
| 6 | Mike | Steve | Scott | Farrelly | Chris | Paul | Steve | Dave |
| 7 | Steve | Mike | Farrelly | Scott | Paul | Chris | Dave | Steve |
| 8 | Farrelly | Paul | Rick | Mike | Mike | Guilmet | Paul | Farrelly |
| 9 | Chris | Dave | Steve | Jeff | Craig | Dave | Scott | Craig |
| 10 | Jeff | Scott | Chris | Dave | Eric | Jeff | Mike | Guilmet |
| 11 | Eric | Rick | Guilmet | Eric | Scott | Steve | Jeff | Chris |
| 12 | Craig | Guilmet | Craig | Paul | Farrelly | Rick | Eric | Rick |
| 17th Round | 18th Round | 19th Round | 20th Round | 21st Round | 22nd Round | 23rd Round | Pre-Season | |
| 1 | Craig | Steve | Steve | Jeff | Dave | Jeff | Jeff | Rick |
| 2 | Jeff | Farrelly | Rick | Scott | Paul | Rick | Scott | Mike |
| 3 | Mike | Rick | Guilmet | Farrelly | Craig | Mike | Paul | Guilmet |
| 4 | Eric | Guilmet | Craig | Mike | Eric | Farrelly | Craig | Dave |
| 5 | Dave | Scott | Chris | Paul | Chris | Guilmet | Eric | Farrelly |
| 6 | Chris | Paul | Eric | Dave | Steve | Scott | Chris | Steve |
| 7 | Paul | Chris | Dave | Eric | Scott | Steve | Steve | Chris |
| 8 | Scott | Dave | Paul | Chris | Guilmet | Chris | Farrelly | Eric |
| 9 | Guilmet | Eric | Mike | Craig | Farrelly | Eric | Dave | Craig |
| 10 | Rick | Mike | Farrelly | Guilmet | Mike | Craig | Guilmet | Paul |
| 11 | Farrelly | Jeff | Scott | Rick | Rick | Paul | Mike | Scott |
| 12 | Steve | Craig | Jeff | Steve | Jeff | Dave | Rick | Jeff |
| Week 1 | Week 2 | Week 3 | Week 4 | Minors 1 | Minors 2 | Extra 1 | Extra 2 | |
| 1 | Steve | Chris | Scott | Jeff | Paul | Guilmet | Paul | Scott |
| 2 | Dave | Eric | Mike | Paul | Rick | Steve | Dave | Guilmet |
| 3 | Craig | Scott | Farrelly | Chris | Eric | Dave | Jeff | Farrelly |
| 4 | Paul | Jeff | Craig | Dave | Craig | Jeff | Craig | Rick |
| 5 | Mike | Guilmet | Rick | Eric | Farrelly | Chris | Steve | Mike |
| 6 | Farrelly | Rick | Steve | Guilmet | Mike | Scott | Eric | Chris |
| 7 | Rick | Farrelly | Guilmet | Steve | Scott | Mike | Chris | Eric |
| 8 | Guilmet | Mike | Eric | Rick | Chris | Farrelly | Mike | Steve |
| 9 | Jeff | Paul | Dave | Craig | Jeff | Craig | Rick | Craig |
| 10 | Scott | Craig | Chris | Farrelly | Dave | Eric | Farrelly | Jeff |
| 11 | Eric | Dave | Paul | Mike | Steve | Rick | Guilmet | Dave |
| 12 | Chris | Steve | Jeff | Scott | Guilmet | Paul | Scott | Paul |